Benfica finish league season undefeated but its a total disappointment

In a campaign defined by remarkable consistency yet haunted by missed opportunities, Benfica completed the 2025-26 Portuguese League season undefeated but finished a shocking third place, condemning them to the UEFA Europa League next season. The Eagles played 34 matches without defeat, recording 23 wins and 11 draws for 80 points. Yet rivals FC Porto (88 points) and Sporting (82 points) edged them out for the top two spots.

Despite the unbeaten run, a feat that would normally guarantee silverware, Benfica's inability to convert dominance into victories against more opposition proved costly. Fans watched in frustration as several draws against mid-table sides proved decisive. The disappointment is compounded by major off-field uncertainty. Manager Jose Mourinho, who returned to Portuguese football with high expectations, is strongly linked with a move to Real Madrid. Los Blancos are reportedly preparing a lucrative offer to bring the "Special One" back to La Liga amid their own transitional period. Mourinho's departure would mark another turbulent chapter for Benfica. 

Adding to the turmoil, veteran defender and team captain Nicolas Otamendi will not renew his contract and leave the club this summer for River Plate, creating a significant void in the heart of the backline. The 38 year-old Argentine World Cup winner, a pillar of Benfica's defense for the past five seasons will need to be replaced by another veteran center back who can provide a calming presence to their young backline. 

Club president Rui Costa faces mounting pressure to stabilize the squad. While the unbeaten record offers pride, third place and European demotion represent a sobering reality of how it does not mean a thing. Benfica must now regroup for the 2026-27 season quickly if they hope to turn historic resilience into future silverware and a return back to Europe's top competition.